Analysis of Reinforced Concrete D-Regions Using Strut-and-Tie Model

Mohamed Husain, Hilal Abd El-Kader Hassan, Mahmoud Khater, Amr Ghoniem


The developed Strut-and-Tie Model (STM) has no unique shape for each load case of a given structural problem as long as the selected idealized internal load-resisting truss is in equilibrium with boundary forces, and also stresses in its components "struts, ties, and nodes" are within acceptable limits. However, the optimal shapes are the well-designed with best ordinal weight number of conditional factors as the rebar amount, the load factor, and the structural concrete ductility. The current study investigates numerically based on FE method stress flow contours and micro truss techniques many alternatives with different shapes of struts and ties that transfer the flow of forces from top of the deep beam with opening to both right and left supports. Then, these alternatives with different concrete characteristics are analyzed by strut-and-tie computational tools using different code provisions for verifying its results accuracy with the numerical nonlinear finite element analysis results for studying the structure performance under applied service loads and over loading till failure. The chosen alternative produce load factor to reach capacity greater than 1, therefore the strut-and-tie method always give demand collapse load lower than the true capacity collapse load. This implies that the solution obtained from STM usually lies on the safe side with conservative sense for concrete structures subjected to service loads. That’s why the STM is emerging as an increasingly popular code-worthy methodology for the design and detailing of concrete structures D-Regions.


D-regions. Strut-and-tie. STM. Strut-and-tie computational tool. CAST. Numerical nonlinear finite element analysis. ANSYS. Reinforced concrete deep beam. Optimal shape.

Full Text:



Ritter, W., “The Hennebique Design Method” (Zürich) (in German), Vol. 33, No. 7, pp. 59-61 (Feb 1899).

Mörcsh, E., "Reinforced Concrete Construction-Theory and Application", 5th Ed., Wittwer, Stutgart, V.1, Part 1, Part 2, (1920, 1922).

Dilger, W. “Veränderlichkeit der Biege-und Schubsteifigkeit bei Stahlbetontragwerken und ihr Einfluβauf Schnittkraftverteilung und Traglast bei statisch unbestimmter Lagerung.’’ Deutscher Ausschuss für Stahlbeton, Heft 179, Berlin, Germany (1966).

Nielsen, M. P. "Limit Analysis and Concrete Plasticity" ,Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey (1984).

Paulay, T. “Coupling Beams of Reinforced Concrete Shear Walls.’’ Journal of the Structural Division, ASCE, 97(ST3), 843–862 (1971).

Thϋrlimann, B., Marti, P., Pralong, J., Ritz, P., and Zimmerli, B. "Application of the theory of plasticity to reinforced concrete" Institute of Structrual Engineering, ETH Zϋrich (1983).

Yun, Y. M., and Ramirez, J. A. “Strength of Struts and Nodes in Strut-and-Tie Model.” Journal of Structural Engineering. V. 122, No. 1, pp 20-29 (January, 1996).

Schlaich, J. and Schäfer, K. “Design and Detailing of Structural Concrete Using Strut-and-Tie Models.” The Structural Engineer. V. 69, No. 6, pp 113-125 (May-June, 1991).

Adebar, P., Kuchma, D., and Collins, M.P., “Strut-and-Tie Models for the Design of Pile Caps: An Experimental Study,”ACI Structural Journal, Vol. 87, No. 1, pg. 81-92 (1990).

Alshegeir, A., J.A. Analysis of Disturbed Regions with Strut-and-Tie Models. Dissertation, Department of Civil Engineering, Purdue University, 274 pp (December 1992).

Adebar, P., and Zhou, Z., "Design of Deep Pile Caps Using Strut-and-Tie Models," ACI Structural Journal, Vol. 93, pp. 437-48 (July/Aug 1996).

Bergmeister, K., Breen, J.E., Jirsa, J.O., and Kreger, M.E., “Detailing for Structural Concrete,” Center for Transportation Research Report CTR 0-1127-3F, Austin, Texas (1993).

Breen, J.E., Burdet, O., Roberts, C., Sanders, D., and Wollmann, G., “Anchorage Zone Reinforcement for Post-Tensioned Concrete Girders,” National Cooperative Highway Research Program Report No. 356, Washington, DC (1994).

Stephen J. Foster and Adnan R. Malik,”Evaluation of Efficiency Factor Models used in Strut-and-Tie Modeling of Non-flexural Members.” J. Str. Engineering, 128(5), p. 569–577 (2002).

Chen, W.F, and Han, D.J. Plasticity for Structural Engineers, Springer-Verlag New York Inc., 606pp (1988).

Stephen J. Foster and Adnan R. Malik ”Evaluation of Efficiency Factor Models used in Strut-and-Tie Modeling of Nonflexural Members.” J. Struct. Eng., 128(5), 569–577 (2002).

D. K. Sahoo; B. Singh; P. Bhargava, "Effect of Inclination on the Strength of Struts", Magazine of Concrete Research, Volume 63, Issue 2, p. 111 –117 (Dec. 2010).

Panjehpour M, Chai HK, Voo YL, "Refinement of Strut-and-Tie Model for Reinforced Concrete Deep Beams", PLOS ONE 10(6): e0130734 (2015).

Vecchio, F. J., and Collins, M. P. "The modified compression-field theory for reinforced concrete elements subjected to shear." Journal of the American Concrete Institute, 83(2), 219-231 (1986).

Collins, M.P., and Mitchell, D., “Rational Approach to Shear Design – The 1984 Canadian Code Provisions,” ACI Journal, Proceedings, Vol. 83, No. 6, pp. 925-933 (Nov-Dec 1986).

Marti, P. "How to treat shear in structural concrete." ACI Structural Journal, 96(3), 408-414 (1999).

Rogowsky, D.M., MacGregor, J.G., Ong, Y.S. Tests of Reinforced Concrete Deep Beams ACI Journal, Vol. 83, Issue 4, p 614-623 (July-August 1986).

Clark, A. P., “Diagonal Tension in Reinforced Concrete Beams,” ACI Journal, V. 48, No. 10, pp. 145 – 156 (1951).

Ferguson, P. M., “Some Implication of Recent Diagonal Tension Tests,” ACI Journal, V. 53, No. 1, pp. 157-172 (1955).

Watstein, D., and Mathey, R. G., “Strains in Beams Having Diagonal Cracks,” ACI Journal, V. 55, No. 12, pp. 717-728 (1958).

Cook W.D and Mitchell, D. Studies of Disturbed Regions near Discontinuities in Reinforced Concrete Members ACI Structural Journal, V. 85, No. 2, p 206-216 (Mar-Apr 1988).

James O. Jirsa, Konrad Bergmeister, Robert Anderson, John E. Breen, David Barton, and Hakim Bouadi, “Experimental Studies of Nodes in Strut-and-Tie Models," Structural Concrete IABSE Colloquium Stuttgart, 1991, Report, International Association for Bridge and Structural Engineering, Zurich, pp. 525–532 (1991).

Siao, W.B. Strut-and-Tie Model for Shear Behavior in Deep Beams and Pile Caps Failing in Diagonal Splitting ACI Structural Journal, Vol. 90, No. 4, p 356-363 (Jul-Aug 1993).

Maxwell, B. S. and Breen, J. E., “Experimental Evaluation of Strut-and-Tie Model Applied to Deep Beam with Opening”, ACI Structural J.V. 97, No. 1, p. 142-148 (Jan.-Feb. 2000).

Yun, Y. M., "Nonlinear Strut-Tie Model Approach for Structural Concrete", ACI Structural Journal, 97(4), p. 581-590 (2000).

Sagaseta, J. & Vollum, R. L., "Shear Design of Short-Span Beams", Magazine of Concrete Research 62 (4), p. 267-282 (2010).

Chen, B.S., Hagenberger, M.J., and Breen, J.E., “Evaluation of Strut-and-Tie Modeling Approach to Dapped Beam with Opening”, ACI Structural Journal, Vol. 99, No. 4, p. 445-450 (2002).

Huang, F.C., Lee, I.S., and Mo, Y.L., “Designing Pier Caps with Strut-and-Tie Models,” Concrete International, Vol. 20, pp. 43-7 (1998).

Brown, M. D., Bayrak, O., “Design Of Deep Beams Using Strut And Tie Models – Part I, II: Evaluating U.S. Provisions, Design Recommendations”, ACI Structural J. V. 105, No. 4, p. 395-413 (July-Aug., 2008).

Ley, M.T., Riding, K.A., Widianto, Bae S., and Breen, J. “Experimental Verification of the Strut and Tie Model Design Method”, ACI Str. J., V. 104, No. 6, p. 749-755 (2007).

A. Arabzadeh, A. R. Rahaie, R. Aghayari,"A Simple Strut-and-Tie Model for Prediction of Ultimate Shear Strength of RC Deep Beams", International J. of Civil Engineering. Vol. 7, No. 3, (Sep. 2009).

To, N. H. T., Ingham, J. M., and Sritharan, S. "Strut-and-tie computer modeling of reinforced concrete bridge portal frames." Bulletin of the New Zealand Society for Earthquake Engineering, 35(3), 165-189 (2002).

Zhang N., Tan K.-H. "Direct strut-and-tie for Single Span and Continuous Deep Beams", Engineering Str. 29(11):2987-3001 (2007).

Carlos Flores, "Performance of Large Scale Steel Fiber Reinforced Concrete Deep Beam with Single Opening under Monotonic Loading", Master Thesis, University of Texas, (2009).

Liang, Q. Q, Uy, B., and Steven, G.P “Performance-Based Optimization for Strut-Tie Modeling of Structural Concrete,” J. of Str. Eng. Vol. 128: p. 815-823 (June 2002).

Yun, Y. M., "Nonlinear Strut-Tie Model Approach for Structural Concrete", ACI Structural Journal, 97(4), p. 581-590 (2000).

Hamed and M.Salem. "The Micro Truss Model: An Innovative Rational Design Approach for Reinforced Concrete", Journal of Advanced Concrete Technology. 2(1), p. 77-87 (2004).

Nagarajan p., U.B. Jayadeep, and Pillai T.M.M. "Application of Micro Truss and Strut and Tie Model for Analysis and Design of Reinforced Concrete Structural Elements", Songklanakarin J. Sci. Technol.31 (6), p. 647-653, (Nov. - Dec. 2009).

AASHTO LRFD 1996 - 2012 Bridge Design Specifications, American Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials, first edition, Washington, DC.

AS3600 (1994) also AS3600 (2001, 2009), Australian Standard for Concrete Structures, North Sydney.

ECP203-07, Egyptian Code of Practice; Ministry of Housing, Cairo, (in Arabic).

ACI 318-08 and Commentary (318R-08) also ACI 318-14 revision, American Concrete Institute, Farmington Hills, Detroit, Michigan, USA.

NZS 3101-1, Part 1: The Design of Concrete Structures, NZS Concrete Design Committee P 3101 for the Standards Council. Concrete Structures Standard, Wellington, 2006.

DIN 1045-1, Part 1: Design and Construction. Berlin, Germany: Deutsches Institut für Normung (DIN-Normen); 2001.

Eurocode 2 EN 1992-1-1 (2004): Design of Concrete Structures, Part 1-1: General Rules and Rules for Buildings.

CEB-FIP MC 90, Design of Concrete Structures, Comité Euro-International du Béton. London: Thomas Telford Services; 1993.

FIP Commission 3 (1999), Practical Design of Structural Concrete, Federation International de la Precontrainte.

Breña, S. F.; and Morrison, M. C., “Factors Affecting Strength of Elements Designed Using Strut-and-Tie Models,” ACI Str. Jo., V. 104, No. 3, (May-June 2007).

ANSYS 13.0, Help Manual Inc.

SAP2000 TM. Advanced 14.0.0, Computer and Structures, Help Manual Inc, Berkeley, CA.

Tjhin, T.N. and Kuchma, D.A. " Computer-Aided Analysis of Reinforced Concrete using a Refined Nonlinear Strut and Tie Model Approach", ACI Structural Journal, Vol. 99, No. 5, p. 586-594, (Sept.-Oct. 2002).


SPSS, Statistical Package for Social Science 17.0, Help Manual Inc, Polar Engineering and Consulting.


  • There are currently no refbacks.